What about the church’s divisions?

What about the church's divisions as a sign of unfinished formation rather than simple failure—how does disunity expose what still needs healing and maturity in the body of Christ?

The Church's divisions are scandalous. They contradict Jesus' prayer that His followers "may be one" so that "the world may believe" (John 17:21). They fragment the body that's supposed to be unified. They give ammunition to skeptics who point at our quarrels and say, "See? Christianity is just another human institution torn apart by the same pride and tribalism that ruins everything else."

All of this is true. Church disunity is a serious problem. But what if it's not only a problem? What if our divisions—painful as they are—also reveal something important about the process of growth, the nature of transformation, and the kind of patience God exercises with His people?

What if the Church's disunity is a sign that we're still becoming what we're meant to be—that formation is incomplete, that healing is underway but not finished, that maturity is the goal rather than the starting point? What if viewing divisions as evidence of unfinished formation rather than simple moral failure helps us respond to them more pastorally, more hopefully, and ultimately more effectively?

The Reality: Divisions Are Real and Grievous

First, we must not minimize the seriousness of Christian disunity. Paul treats division in the church as spiritually immature and carnally driven: "You are still worldly. For since there is jealousy and quarreling among you, are you not worldly? Are you not acting like mere humans?" (1 Corinthians 3:3). The Corinthians' factionalism—"I follow Paul," "I follow Apollos," "I follow Cephas"—was evidence that they were still thinking with the mindset of the fallen world rather than the renewed mind of Christ.

Jesus' high priestly prayer makes clear that unity is not optional or peripheral: "May they be brought to complete unity to let the world know that you sent me and have loved them even as you have loved me" (John 17:23). The Church's unity is meant to be a visible sign of the gospel's power. When we're divided, our witness is compromised. The world sees us at each other's throats and reasonably questions whether we've actually been transformed by the God we claim to serve.

Throughout history, the Church has split over theology, power, ethnicity, worship style, personality conflicts, and a thousand other issues. We've excommunicated, anathematized, and sometimes even killed one another. The body meant to demonstrate reconciliation has often modeled bitter tribalism. This is tragic—a deep wound in the body of Christ that grieves the Spirit and hinders the mission.

So let's be clear: division is sin. It violates God's purposes. It needs to be lamented, confessed, and fought against. But having said that, we can also recognize that our divisions reveal where formation is needed and what still requires healing.

Formation as Process, Not Event

The New Testament consistently speaks of Christian maturity as a process rather than an instant achievement. We're being "transformed into [Christ's] image with ever-increasing glory" (2 Corinthians 3:18). We're urged to "grow up into him who is the Head, that is, Christ" (Ephesians 4:15). Paul describes his work as "warning and teaching everyone with all wisdom, so that we may present everyone fully mature in Christ" (Colossians 1:28)—an ongoing effort, not a completed task.

Peter tells us to "grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ" (2 Peter 3:18). John addresses his readers as "dear children," "young men," and "fathers"—suggesting stages of spiritual development (1 John 2:12-14). The consistent picture is that conversion is the beginning, not the end. We're justified instantaneously by faith, but we're sanctified progressively by the Spirit's work over a lifetime.

If individual Christians are in process—still being formed, still maturing, still working out their salvation with fear and trembling (Philippians 2:12)—then how much more is the corporate body of Christ in process? The Church as a whole is being "built together to become a dwelling in which God lives by his Spirit" (Ephesians 2:22). Construction is underway. The building is not yet finished.

This means we should expect the Church to exhibit signs of incompleteness. We're a community of people who've been rescued from darkness but still carry wounds, bad habits, distorted thinking, and immature reactions from our past. We're learning to walk in the light, but we still stumble. We're being conformed to Christ, but the process isn't complete. And nowhere is this incompleteness more visible than in our divisions.

What Divisions Reveal

When we view disunity through the lens of unfinished formation, we can ask: What do our divisions tell us about what still needs to be healed and matured in us?

1. Worldly Patterns Not Yet Renounced

Paul's critique of the Corinthian factions is that they're acting "like mere humans"—which is to say, they're operating by the world's logic rather than the gospel's logic. The world forms tribes around charismatic leaders, competes for status and influence, and defines itself over against "the other." When the Church does the same, it reveals that worldly patterns haven't yet been fully renounced.

Division along racial, ethnic, socioeconomic, or cultural lines exposes that we're still thinking tribally—still viewing people through the categories of the Powers rather than seeing them as brothers and sisters in Christ. The early church struggled with this intensely. Jewish and Gentile believers had to learn that in Christ there is "neither Jew nor Gentile" (Galatians 3:28). It wasn't easy. It took conflict, conversation, and the Spirit's intervention (Acts 10-15). Their division revealed what needed formation: a new imagination about identity, belonging, and boundaries.

Our contemporary divisions often reveal the same thing. When churches split along political lines, it shows that political ideology has more formative power in our lives than the gospel. When they split along class lines, it shows we haven't yet embodied the radical economic sharing of Acts 2 and 4. When they split along racial lines, it shows we haven't yet let the gospel dismantle the categories that the Powers use to divide and dominate.

These divisions aren't just moral failures—they're diagnostic. They show us where the Powers still have a grip, where the world's logic still governs our thinking, where formation into Christlikeness is incomplete.

2. Immature Grasp of Truth

Many doctrinal divisions arise not from simple error on one side but from immature or incomplete understanding on both sides. Paul writes, "Now we know in part and we prophesy in part... Now I know in part; then I shall know fully" (1 Corinthians 13:9, 12). Our theological understanding is always partial, always in process, always subject to refinement as we grow.

This doesn't mean all doctrinal positions are equally valid—some are more faithful to Scripture than others. But it does mean that even true doctrines can be held immaturely: with pride, with lack of charity, with failure to integrate them into the whole counsel of God, or with inability to distinguish between essentials and secondary matters.

When Christians divide over issues that aren't central to the gospel (mode of baptism, worship style, eschatological timelines, church governance), it often reveals immaturity: an inability to hold convictions with humility, a failure to love across differences, or an elevation of secondary issues to primary importance. The division points to the need for deeper wisdom, greater discernment about what matters most, and more Christlike charity.

Even when the division is over something truly important (the deity of Christ, justification by faith), the manner of division can reveal immaturity. Do we engage with patience and grace, seeking to persuade and restore? Or do we immediately anathematize, caricature, and declare war? The latter suggests that while we may have right doctrine, we haven't yet been fully formed in the character of Christ.

3. Unhealed Wounds and Trauma

Some divisions stem from real harm: abuse of authority, betrayal of trust, institutional cover-ups, spiritual manipulation. When people leave churches or denominations because they've been wounded, the division itself is a symptom of something broken that hasn't yet been healed.

These divisions reveal the Church's ongoing need for repentance, truth-telling, justice, and restorative practices. They expose places where power has been abused, where the vulnerable have been ignored, where sin has been hidden rather than confronted. The fact that victims must often leave to find healing—rather than finding healing within their communities—shows how far we are from being the safe, restorative body Christ intends.

Such divisions aren't evidence that the victims are spiritually immature. Rather, they're evidence that the institutions are immature—lacking the wisdom, humility, and courage to face their sins, make amends, and create cultures of genuine safety and accountability.

4. Inadequate Love

Jesus said that the world would recognize His disciples by their love for one another (John 13:35). When that love is absent or weak, division becomes inevitable. Paul's great hymn to love in 1 Corinthians 13 comes in the middle of his discussion of spiritual gifts and unity—because love is what holds diverse members together.

Division often reveals that love hasn't yet matured to the point where it can bear differences, endure disagreements, and remain committed through conflict. Immature love says, "I'll stay as long as things go my way." Mature love says, "I'll stay and work through this because we belong to each other in Christ."

When churches split over preferences (music style, preaching length, decor choices), it exposes love that's conditional, shallow, or self-focused. The division reveals where love needs to grow—where we need to learn forbearance, patience, and the ability to esteem others above ourselves.

5. Insufficient Spiritual Warfare Awareness

Paul warns that "our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against... the spiritual forces of evil" (Ephesians 6:12). Yet how often do we treat church conflicts as if they're merely interpersonal disputes, forgetting that the Powers actively work to divide the body?

Division can reveal our naiveté about spiritual warfare. When we fail to recognize that Satan "masquerades as an angel of light" (2 Corinthians 11:14), we can be manipulated into conflicts that serve his purposes. When we're not "alert and of sober mind" because "your enemy the devil prowls around like a roaring lion looking for someone to devour" (1 Peter 5:8), we become easy prey to division.

Our disunity exposes where we need more spiritual maturity: more prayer, more discernment of spirits, more awareness that our real enemy is not the brother or sister we disagree with but the Powers that want to fragment us. Formation here means learning to fight the right enemy, in the right way, with the right weapons.

The Patience of God

Here's a crucial insight: God is patient with our disunity in the same way He's patient with our other sins. He doesn't immediately strike down divided churches, just as He doesn't immediately strike down proud believers or greedy congregations. His patience is meant to lead to repentance (Romans 2:4).

The fact that the Church has survived two millennia of division—often severe, sometimes bloody—and is still here, still growing globally, still bearing witness to Christ, testifies to God's faithfulness. He's committed to finishing what He started (Philippians 1:6). The Church is His bride, and He's determined to present her "holy and blameless" (Ephesians 5:27), even if that requires a long, patient process of washing, sanctifying, and maturing.

This doesn't excuse our divisions or make them acceptable. But it does contextualize them within God's redemptive plan. He's working with broken, immature, wounded people—and He's not surprised that we're not instantly perfect. He knew from the beginning that formation would take time, that sanctification is progressive, that even Paul and Barnabas would have such a sharp disagreement that they'd part ways (Acts 15:39).

Moving Toward Maturity

If disunity reveals unfinished formation, then the path forward is not merely denouncing division but actively pursuing the maturity that overcomes it. This involves several commitments:

1. Humility About Our Own Partiality

We must acknowledge that we "know in part." Our theological understanding is incomplete. Our cultural biases affect our interpretation. Our personal experiences shape what we emphasize. This doesn't mean all views are equally valid, but it should make us slower to condemn and quicker to listen.

Humility creates space for unity across differences. When I recognize that I might be wrong, or at least that I don't see everything clearly, I can engage with those who disagree as fellow learners rather than as enemies to defeat.

2. Prioritizing Love Over Being Right

Paul doesn't say that knowledge is unimportant—he's deeply concerned about right doctrine. But he insists that "knowledge puffs up while love builds up" (1 Corinthians 8:1). We can be technically correct in our theology while utterly failing in love—and if we do, we're "only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal" (1 Corinthians 13:1).

Pursuing maturity means learning to hold our convictions with love, to disagree without demonizing, to correct without crushing. It means asking, "Is my manner of engaging this conflict reflecting Christ, or am I just enjoying the fight?"

3. Distinguishing Essentials from Non-Essentials

The old maxim applies: "In essentials, unity; in non-essentials, liberty; in all things, charity." But we need discernment to know which is which. Not every theological difference is worth dividing over. The deity of Christ? Non-negotiable. Eschatological timeline? Much less central. Style of worship? Even less.

Maturity involves learning to hold firm on what truly matters while extending generous space for diversity on what doesn't. This requires ongoing conversation, biblical study, and Spirit-led discernment in community.

4. Actively Pursuing Reconciliation

Jesus commands, "If your brother or sister sins, go and point out their fault, just between the two of you" (Matthew 18:15). We're not to gossip, factionalize, or withdraw—we're to engage directly, humbly, and with the goal of restoration.

This is hard work. It requires courage to confront, humility to be confronted, patience to work through misunderstanding, and grace to forgive. But it's the work of maturity. Churches that practice Matthew 18 well rarely split. Churches that avoid conflict or handle it carnally frequently do.

5. Cultivating Spiritual Practices That Form Unity

Worship, prayer, the Lord's Supper, Scripture study—these aren't just individual practices but corporate ones that form us together into one body. When we worship side by side with people different from us, our hearts are gradually aligned. When we pray together, we're reminded of our shared dependence on God. When we share the Eucharist, we're proclaiming our common participation in Christ's body.

Churches that neglect these corporate spiritual disciplines tend toward fragmentation because they lack the shared practices that create common identity and affection.

6. Lament and Repentance

Finally, we need to lament our divisions honestly before God and repent of the pride, fear, and selfishness that drive them. Lament acknowledges the pain and tragedy of disunity. Repentance turns us away from the attitudes and actions that perpetuate it.

Denominations and congregations that have split need to tell the truth about what happened, own their part in it, and seek reconciliation where possible. Even when full institutional reunification isn't feasible, we can pursue relational healing, mutual recognition, and cooperative mission.

Hope for the Future

The Church's divisions are not the final word. Scripture promises a day when the "multitude that no one could count, from every nation, tribe, people and language" will stand unified before the throne, worshiping together (Revelation 7:9). The disunity we experience now is real, but it's not ultimate.

In the meantime, every effort toward greater unity—every reconciled relationship, every bridge built across theological or cultural divides, every congregation that models love across difference—is a foretaste of that coming day. It's a sign that the Spirit is still at work, still forming us, still moving us toward maturity.

Our divisions reveal where we need to grow. The question is whether we'll cooperate with the Spirit's work of formation or resist it. Will we cling to our tribalism, our pride, our need to be right? Or will we humble ourselves, pursue love, and let God mature us into the unified body He intends?

The Church's disunity is both a tragedy and a diagnosis. It's a tragedy because it contradicts our calling. But it's also a diagnosis—a revelation of where the healing work of the Spirit still needs to reach, where formation is incomplete, where Christ is still patiently, lovingly working to make us into His image.

We're not there yet. But by God's grace, we're on the way.

Thoughtful Questions to Consider

What divisions in your own church experience have revealed areas where you personally needed to grow in maturity, humility, or love?
How might viewing theological opponents as fellow learners (rather than enemies) change the way you engage in doctrinal disagreements?
In your context, what practices or disciplines could help cultivate greater unity across differences without compromising conviction on essentials?
Where have you seen division that seems less about theology and more about unhealed wounds or unacknowledged trauma—and how might the church respond to that differently?
If you're part of a divided or contentious faith community, what would it look like to stay and work for reconciliation rather than simply leaving? What makes that difficult?

What About...?

Search This Blog